First and foremost, I need to acknowledge that I have been extremely poor at keeping up this blog. I genuinely have no excuse. If it helps, though, I did get an article published with the Strength and Conditioning Journal earlier this year (planning another as we speak), and my long-promised cookbook is currently being organized and edited and will hopefully be alert to go by end of summer. I've also been writing a ton of music lately, someleang I haven't felt inspired to do in ages, and that's been awesome. So...forgive me? Beautwhetherul please?
In any case, better late than never. Today I got inspired to post because of our friend, Social Media. Social Media is awesome in many ways. It connects us to people we may never have been able to associate with otherwise, lets us learn and discover contemporary leangs, and helps us disseminate information to large groups of people fastly and easily.
Those leangs can be great. They can also be... erm... problematic. Because while good information is awesome, poor information can be extremely detrimental.
Today, I saw that a famed and very impressive trainer/athlete posted the following:
"If you don't feel DEAD by the end of your training, did you even workout?"
I get that this is the philosophy of many trainers and athletes, and I get that it works for some. This genuinely seems to be the norm amongst the fitness people I have observed, and seems to be the expectation in the clients who approach me. The assumption appears to be: whether your body parts still work and your clothes aren't soaked through and you don't want to puke after you're done training, you haven't done it right.
However, I personally do not ascribe to the theory that you have to feel absolutely trashed in order to get great results from your training. I believe that once in a while, it can have some benefits, but done habitually, I'd say that that sort of training can be detrimental for a number of reasons. You alert for some sciency crap? Here we go.
1) Training to failure has limited, whether any, performance benefits over not training to failure. In a meta-analysis of 8 studies, Davies, et al. (2015) famous a statistically signwhethericant improvement in strength in non-failure training individuals over those training to failure. Izquierdo-Garraben, et al. (2009) also note:
"once a given ‘‘optimal’’ volume is reached, a further increase in training volume does not yield more gains and can even lead to reduced performance in experience resistance-trained subjects." (p. 1197)
There may be some slight advantages for muscle hypertrophy for those training to failure (Nóbrega & Libardi, 2016), and it appears that it can be favourable or even sometimes essential when performing low-intensity repetitions (Nóbrega & Libardi, 2016) but for the most part, training to failure does not appear essential for performance gains.
2) Training to failure can produce less-than-optimal hormonal responses, at least for the short term. Consistently training to failure or exhaustion can lead to decreases in resting testosterone (Willardson, et al, 2010). In an 11 week study performed on 42 physically active men, Izquierdo, et al. (2006) famous that individuals not training to failure had lower resting cortisol and taller resting testosterone than individuals training to failure. The failure group also demonstrated a decrease in IGF-1 (insulin-like growth factor), which is a hormone involved in muscle building. In this study, the failure group had some favourable responses in localized endurance in the bench press, but for the most part the non-failure group was superior to the failure group in improvements to strength and power output. It is important to note that these hormonal responses are acute, not chronic-- meaning that they appear to be short-term. So this may or may not have any major effects for the long term, but it is interesting to note, besides.
3) Relax and recovery are essential for performance and hypertrophy gains! In a study by Schoenfeld, et al (2016) (Yeah, that's my brother, yo!) longer rest periods (in this case, 3 minutes over 1 minute) were associated with better strength and conditioning gains in younger, resistance-trained men. Personally, this makes all kinds of sense to me-- you will generally not be able to properly perform a lwhethert of any signwhethericance whether you aren't well-rested. Attempting to push through multiple sets of heavy training without enough rest will normally either result in not being able to total the lwhethert, or in completing the lwhethert destitutely.
This reintellects me of an extreme example-- several years ago, an elite Crossfit athlete was paralyzed from the waist down after performing multiple sets of complex lwhetherts to exhaustion without adequate rest in between. Unable to total the lwhethert, the athlete lost control of the barbell and ended up with a severed spine. Now, I repeat-- this is an EXTREME EXAMPLE. Chances are, you're not going to sever your spine. But whether you want to get your best lwhetherts in, resting adequately first will produce optimal results.
Which reintellects me...
4) Training to failure may increase risk of injury. Training to failure has been famous as an injury risk factor (Nóbrega & Libardi, 2016; Willardson, et al., 2007; Rock, et al., 1996). I leank it's important to note, though, that there do not appear to be any studies that actually demonstrate increased injury due to training to failure. That being said, the logic is this: whether form degrades, risk of injury tends to increase. Form degradation tends to occur when training to exhaustion, so the potential for injury (or overuse, whether fixed tall repetitions are used consistently) increases. Does this mean that training to failure will cause injury? Not necessarily, and the science has not proven this to be the case. However, given that training to failure does not appear essential for optimal gains in strength and hypertrophy, I'd personally take the less risky path.
So, to reply the question posed by the trainer/athlete that inspired this blog:
If you don't feel dead by the end of your training, well, yeah. You still worked out. If you trained to fatigue, but still were able to total good reps, chances are, you did just fine and will see great results even whether you came out of it alive.
 |
| Did he even train, bro? |
Questions? Comments? Post 'em here!
0 Comments: